Mental Health

“Designed Without Us”: How Excluding Women from Clinical Research Still Shapes Our Mental Health

March 18, 2026

Your experience is data. Learn how gaps in research still shape women’s mental health and how to reconnect with your body.

The Power of Self-Care: Why It Matters and How to Start Today
The Power of Self-Care: Why It Matters and How to Start Today
The Power of Self-Care: Why It Matters and How to Start Today
Now Trending:
I'm SONYA!

I'm here to help you live and love your life to the fullest with my feel-good health and wellness tips and resources.

hello,

Ready to take your life and wellness to the next level?

JOIN ME IN

Discover more of my wellness resources.

When a provider hands you a new prescription or diagnosis, it can feel like you’re stepping into something solid and evidence-based.

But for decades in the United States, women were routinely left out of the very clinical trials that built that “evidence.”

This means much of modern medicine, including mental health treatment, was not originally designed with women’s bodies, hormones, or nervous systems in mind.

Understanding this history is one way we begin to reclaim agency over our care, our bodies, and our healing.

How Women Were Written Out of the Data

The exclusion of women from clinical trials wasn’t just a series of oversights; it was codified in policy.

In 1977, the FDA issued guidance advising researchers to exclude “any premenopausal woman capable of becoming pregnant” from early-phase drug studies. (Source)

On paper, this sounded protective. In reality, it removed the majority of adult women from early safety and dosing research, even if they were using contraception or did not plan to become pregnant.

This policy grew out of understandable fear after tragedies like thalidomide. But it created a different kind of harm: medications were tested primarily in men, then prescribed broadly to women without truly knowing how those drugs would land in a female body.

By the late 1980s, federal reviews showed that many key pre-approval trials for FDA-approved drugs either underrepresented women or included them in numbers too small to draw meaningful conclusions.(Source)

In other words, the “average patient” in much of the research was male, even as women filled waiting rooms, pharmacies, and therapy offices.

1993: A Policy Shift, Not a Full Repair

A major shift came with the NIH Revitalization Act of 1993, which required that women and minorities be included in NIH-funded clinical research, and that sex-specific analyses be conducted where appropriate. (Source)

Over time, the FDA rescinded its 1977 guidance, and new policies began to encourage, not discourage, the inclusion of women in trials.

Many psychiatric medications already on the market had been developed and approved based on male-dominant trials, and they remain in use today, often without robust information on how they affect women across different ages and hormonal life stages.

What This Means for Women’s Mental Health

Women are more likely than men to experience anxiety and depression and often carry a higher burden of trauma, stress-related conditions, and chronic pain. Yet psychiatric trials have not always reflected this reality.

  • Women’s bodies process medications differently.
    Body composition, hormones, liver enzymes, and gut function can all influence how drugs move through the system.
  • Women may be more vulnerable to certain side effects.
    Some may require different dosing patterns than what standard guidelines suggest.
  • Hormonal life phases matter.
    The menstrual cycle, pregnancy, postpartum, perimenopause, and menopause all influence mood, sleep, inflammation, and nervous system regulation… yet many medications have not been thoroughly studied across these phases.

And from a somatic standpoint, this means that when your body responds differently to a medication than expected, more fatigue, more anxiety, more agitation, you’re not being “difficult” or “too sensitive.”

Gender Bias in the Room: How Women Are Seen and Heard

The data gap is only one piece of the story. The other is how women are treated when they show up for care.

Historically, women’s distress has been reframed as “hysteria,” “moodiness,” or “overreacting,” rather than recognized as valid signals that something may be out of balance, biologically, psychologically, or socially.

  • Women’s physical symptoms are being minimized or misattributed to anxiety without thorough evaluation
  • Feeling dismissed or not believed when reporting side effects or intuitive concerns
  • Higher rates of anxiety and depression diagnoses that can sometimes obscure other conditions (like ADHD, bipolar disorder, autoimmune issues, or hormonal imbalances)

For women with a history of trauma, these experiences can feel like another rupture in safety.

Being rushed, talked over, or told “it’s just stress” can echo earlier experiences of not being protected or believed. The nervous system registers this as a threat, and the body may respond with shutdown, fawning, or heightened fight-or-flight right in the middle of the appointment.

A Somatic, Integrative Lens: Listening to Women’s Bodies

One way to respond to this history is to center women’s bodies and nervous systems as valid, primary sources of data, not afterthoughts.

In practice, this can look like:

  • Tracking your body’s signals
    Notice sensations — tightness, fluttering, heaviness, heat, numbness before and after medications, appointments, or stress.
  • Connecting symptoms with cycles
    Map mood, sleep, cravings, pain, and energy across your menstrual cycle or hormonal transitions.
  • Honoring your pace
    Somatic work emphasizes slowness, safety, and expanding your window of tolerance—rather than pushing through.
  • Integrating mind and body
    Blending psychotherapy with practices like breathwork, gentle movement, tapping, or somatic experiencing.

This doesn’t mean medication is “bad” or unnecessary. It means you’re invited into a more collaborative relationship with your care:

How does this land in my body?
What shifts in my nervous system?
What do I need alongside this to truly feel supported?

Reclaim Your Inner Authority! Here are some Helpful Reflection Prompts:

You might wanna pause with a notebook or simply a quiet moment and explore:

  • Where have I felt dismissed or not believed in medical or mental health spaces? What did my body do in those moments?
  • How does my body communicate “yes” and “no”? What sensations signal alignment vs. misalignment?
  • If my symptoms are intelligent signals, what might they be asking me to pay attention to right now?
  • What kind of support does my nervous system need more of… slowness, warmth, boundaries, nourishment, movement, rest, or connection?

These questions don’t replace medical care. But they bring you back into the center of your healing.

A Call to Women: Your Experience Is Data!

The history of women’s exclusion from clinical research can feel frustrating, and it can also be clarifying.

It helps explain why your intuition may have felt at odds with what you’ve been told in medical spaces.
It validates the part of you that has thought, “This doesn’t feel right in my body.”

As a woman navigating mental health care today, you are allowed to:

  • Ask how much of the evidence behind a treatment includes women like you
  • Bring your somatic experience, hormonal shifts, and trauma history into the room
  • Seek providers who understand nervous system regulation and integrative mental health

How I Support Women in This Work

In my practice, I integrate clinical mental health care with functional and somatic approaches to help women make sense of both their symptoms and their stories.

This may include:

  • Exploring the connection between hormones, inflammation, gut health, and mood
  • Using body-based practices to release stored survival energy and build safety
  • Collaborating with prescribing providers so your treatment reflects both research and lived experience

There is nothing wrong with you for feeling the way you do. Your body has been navigating systems that were not designed with you at the center.

If you’re ready for more aligned, integrative, and nervous-system-honoring support, I invite you to take the next step, whether that’s booking a session, joining a group, or starting with a guided resource.

Your experience is data.
Your body is wise.
And your healing deserves to be grounded in both science and the truth of your lived experience.

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Browse By Category

NUTRITION

Stress

MENTAL HEALTH

HSP

WELLNESS

FITNESS

so hot right now

hey there!

Discover the joy of feeling your best every day!

I believe that true wellness encompasses a healthy mind, a vibrant body, and a life you absolutely love. Achieving this balance requires a dedicated commitment to positive change.

I am here to guide you in identifying and addressing your imbalances, restoring both your mental and physical health.

Together, we can help you live a more fulfilled and vibrant life.

more about me

Psychiatry Needs a Facelift!

MENTAL HEALTH

What is an Highly Sensitive Person (HSP)?
 

HSP

READ HERE

SONYA DAVIE WELLNESS RESOURCES

READ HERE

Ready to fall in love with feeling good?

You will love my newsletter!

    Upgrade your mental wellness and stress reduction!

    Join my email list and receive newsletters packed with lifestyle tips, wellness insights, and the latest information in integrative and functional psychiatry.

    Life is good when you feel good!

    © Sonya Davie Wellness, LLC 2024 | 
    Website Design Template by Tonic 

    EVENTS
    SHOP
    BLOG
    HSP CORNER
    BOOTCAMP
    ABOUT
    HOME

    LET's CONNECT >

    GET ON THE LIST >

    @SONYADAVIE >

    follow along 
    on Instagram:

    The content provided by this site is for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide personal medical advice, which should be obtained from a medical professional.

    Disclaimer:

    Sonya Davie Wellness, sonyadavie.com, is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.